Comparative analysis of deep learning models for defect detection in additive manufacturing using thermal imaging

Thermal imaging has emerged as a promising approach for real-time defect detection in additive manufacturing, yet the optimal deep learning architecture for this application remains unclear due to limited comparative studies. This study addresses this research gap by conducting a comprehensive benchmarking analysis of seven distinct deep learning architectures for thermal imaging-based defect detection in additive manufacturing. We systematically evaluated classical networks (VGG16, AlexNet), modern efficient designs (ResNet18, MobileNetV2, EfficientNet-B0), a hybrid approach (Hybrid VGG-AlexNet), and a Proposed custom CNN approach using similar training conditions and a balanced dataset of 21,127 thermal printing images spanning five defect categories. Our comparative analysis reveals that multiple architectures achieve competitive performance: top performers reached 97.26 % (custom architecture), 97.19 % (ResNet18), and 97.07 % (MobileNetV2) accuracy, while hybrid approaches achieved 93.72 % accuracy. Also, The Proposed CNN demonstrates a balanced memory profile, with moderate parameter count and efficient memory usage (1.91 GB), making it a promising candidate for deployment in resource-constrained environments. The results demonstrate the system’s effectiveness within controlled experimental conditions and its effectiveness in identifying anomalies such as under-extrusion, over-extrusion, and warping. These findings offer practitioners actionable insights for balancing accuracy, computational efficiency, and deployment requirements in additive manufacturing quality control systems.