Conceptually Misaligned: Black Being, the Human, and Fungibility

This article concerns the ways in which Afropessimist Calvin Warren misuses and overextends both Wynter's historiography of the Human and Hartman's concept "fungible commodity."First, Calvin Warren flattens the ontology of the political subject described in Wynter's concept "genres of Man"to argue that the contemporary Black US person exists as "being,"that is, non-being. Second, Warren misaligns with Wynter's account of the period of historical rupture between the Human and nonhuman. Whereas, for Wynter, this rupture was constituted by the colonial encounter in the Americas, Warren cites chattel slavery as the event wherein the Human and Other, specifically the Black Other, were torn apart. Third, Warren's use of "fungible commodity"when referencing the contemporary Black lacks a historiographical framework that would account for the continued non-being of Black existence as commodity post-emancipation.