TY - JOUR
T1 - Demography’s Changing Intellectual Landscape
T2 - A Bibliometric Analysis of the Leading Anglophone Journals, 1950–2020
AU - Merli, M. Giovanna
AU - Moody, James
AU - Verdery, Ashton
AU - Yacoub, Mark
N1 - Funding Information:
Our analyses generalize to publications in the three leading journals of demography that together span the last seven decades of anglophone demography. Our main corpus consists of all articles published in Demography, Population Studies, and Population and Development Review (PDR) between the year of a journal’s first issue through the last issue of 2020, excluding comments, replies, and book reviews. While demography as a field emerged from interdisciplinary efforts in the first half of the twentieth century (Merchant 2017, 2021), our focus is on the period when the field established its key outlets of intellectual and scholarly communication. Population Studies is the oldest of the three, established in 1947 with funds from the Rockefeller Foundation. The Population Association of America established its flagship journal, Demography, in 1964, with a grant from the Ford Foundation. Population and Development Review was established in 1975 and became an outlet for demographic studies that did not fit the traditional mold. At the time of its founding by the Population Council, Population and Development Review devoted considerably less space to quantitative and formal analyses than did either of the other two journals (Merchant 2015:577). These three journals offer the longest, continuous coverage of the last 70 years of anglophone demography publications. They have been recognized as the triad defining the field of population research in terms of citations to and from other demography journals during the 1990s (van Dalen and Henkens 1999:247) and, as journals specifically concerned with demography, they have maintained the highest impact factors of all demography journals during the first two decades of the twenty-first century, according to Journal Citation Reports.2
Funding Information:
Acknowledgments The authors thank Sara Curran, Noreen Goldman, Daniel Goodkind, Mark Hayward, Jennifer Johnson-Hanks, Grant Miller, Angela O’Rand, Samuel Preston, Herbert Smith, and four anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments on early versions of this article. Support for this research was provided by NICHD grant P2CHD065563.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2023 The Authors.
PY - 2023/6/1
Y1 - 2023/6/1
N2 - Much of what we know about the intellectual landscape of anglophone demography comes from two sources: subjective narratives authored by leaders in the field, whose reviews and observations are derived from their research experience and field-specific knowledge; and professional histories covering the field’s foundational controversies, which tend to focus on individuals, institutions, and influence. Here we use bibliographic information from all articles published in the three leading journals of anglophone demography—Demography, Population Studies, and Population and Development Review—to survey the changing contours of anglophone demography’s key research areas over the past 70 years. We characterize the field of demography by applying a two-pronged, data-grounded approach from the sociology of science. The first uses natural language processing that lets the substance of the field emerge from the con tents of pub li ca tion records and applies social network ana ly ses to iden tify groups of papers that talk about the same thing. The second uses bibliometric tools to capture the “conversations” of demography with other disciplines. Our goals are to (1) identify the primary topics of demography since the discipline first gained prominence as an organized field; (2) assess changes in the field’s intellectual cohesion and the top-i cal areas that have grown or shrunk; and (3) examine how demographers place their work in relationship to other disciplines, the visibility and influence of demographic research in the broader scien tific liter a ture, and the cross-disci plin ary transla tional reach of demographic research. Results provide a dynamic view of the field’s scientific development in the second half of the twentieth century and the first two decades of the twenty-first century.
AB - Much of what we know about the intellectual landscape of anglophone demography comes from two sources: subjective narratives authored by leaders in the field, whose reviews and observations are derived from their research experience and field-specific knowledge; and professional histories covering the field’s foundational controversies, which tend to focus on individuals, institutions, and influence. Here we use bibliographic information from all articles published in the three leading journals of anglophone demography—Demography, Population Studies, and Population and Development Review—to survey the changing contours of anglophone demography’s key research areas over the past 70 years. We characterize the field of demography by applying a two-pronged, data-grounded approach from the sociology of science. The first uses natural language processing that lets the substance of the field emerge from the con tents of pub li ca tion records and applies social network ana ly ses to iden tify groups of papers that talk about the same thing. The second uses bibliometric tools to capture the “conversations” of demography with other disciplines. Our goals are to (1) identify the primary topics of demography since the discipline first gained prominence as an organized field; (2) assess changes in the field’s intellectual cohesion and the top-i cal areas that have grown or shrunk; and (3) examine how demographers place their work in relationship to other disciplines, the visibility and influence of demographic research in the broader scien tific liter a ture, and the cross-disci plin ary transla tional reach of demographic research. Results provide a dynamic view of the field’s scientific development in the second half of the twentieth century and the first two decades of the twenty-first century.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85161594222&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85161594222&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1215/00703370-10714127
DO - 10.1215/00703370-10714127
M3 - Article
C2 - 37166269
AN - SCOPUS:85161594222
SN - 0070-3370
VL - 60
SP - 865
EP - 890
JO - Demography
JF - Demography
IS - 3
ER -