Investigation of breakaway corrosion observed during oxide growth in pure and low alloying element content Zr exposed in water at 360°C

The addition of small concentrations of alloying elements to pure zirconium can prevent nuclear fuel cladding material from undergoing unstable oxide growth in aqueous environments at light water reactor operating temperatures. The role of alloying elements in stabilizing the oxide growth is examined in this paper, to better understand the oxide growth stabilization mechanism. To this end, a set of initial, short-duration corrosion experiments were performed, followed by oxide layer characterization. Specifically, ten model Zr alloys were selected to test the effect of small alloying additions on the alloy corrosion rate and corrosion breakaway. These alloys were corrosion tested in pure water in an autoclave at 360 °C for up to 70 days. The alloys included crystal bar Zr, sponge Zr, and model alloys with small concentrations of Sn, Fe, and Cr. After testing, the alloys were characterized using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and synchrotron µ-X-ray fluorescence (µXRF) to study how the structure of the oxide and alloying element distribution related to unstable oxide growth. Initial results in the 360 °C water environment showed breakaway oxidation may be caused by unstable oxide growth due to heterogeneous distribution of the alloying elements. Heterogeneous distribution of alloying elements was correlated to the occurrence of unstable oxide growth (either nodule-like, grain boundary penetration, or differential grain-to-grain growth). It is possible that this heterogeneity, made possible by low alloying element content, can cause breakaway corrosion, but further study is warranted.