Severe phenotypes associated with inactive ring X chromosomes

Mental retardation and congenital malformations in individuals with small ring X chromosomes are often due to the functional disomy that results from failure of these chromosomes to undergo X inactivation. Such chromosomes either lack the XIST locus or do not express it. We have carried out genetic analysis of the ring X chromosomes from two girls with a 45,X/46,X,r(X) karyotype, mental retardation, and a constellation of abnormalities characteristic of the severe phenotype due to X disomy. In each case the ring X chromosome included an intact XIST locus which was expressed; the breakpoints were distal to DXS128, and therefore outside the XIC region; transcription analysis of alleles at the androgen receptor locus confirmed that these were inactive chromosomes. The characteristics of the XIST RNA were similar to the wild-type. Additional studies in cultured fibroblasts showed a second ring in a small percentage of the cells. The association of severe phenotype with an inactive X chromosome most likely reflects the presence of a second ring X chromosome which was active at least in some tissues during embryogenesis, but is no longer prominent in the tissues we analyzed.