Structure-mutagenicity relationships of chalcones and their oxides in the Salmonella assay

31 p-monosubstituted chalcones (E-1, 3-diphenylpropene-1-one) and the corresponding oxides (E-1-benzoyl-2-phenyloxirane) were tested for mutagenic activity on two strains of Salmonella typhimurium (TA98 and TA100) with and without rat liver microsomal and cytosolic enzymes. Highest mutagenicity (3.0 revertants/nmole in either strain) was seen with the 4-nitrochalcone, especially after S9 activation. Epoxidation, in general, increased the mutagenic activity of the respective chalcone. Benzoyl (4′) substituted chalcones and their oxides with an electron-withdrawing substituent (e.g., nitro, fluoro) usually had higher activity than their phenyl (4) substituted counterparts, whereas the converse was the case with electron-donating substituents (e.g., acetamido, methoxy). Further multiple factorial analysis revealed that increasing hydrophilicity as indicated by the Hansch π parameter, and resonance electronic contributions were more important than other factors including steric terms in explaining the mutagenicity of these compounds. Mutagenic effects of some chalcone oxides, particularly the 4-methoxy derivative, were markedly decreased by S9 treatment. The consequence of the weak-to-moderate mutagenicity of these compounds to dietary intake of hydroxylated and methoxylated chalcones is discussed.