The Severity of Initial Unilateral Cleft Lip and Nasal Deformity Predicts Long-Term Postoperative Esthetic Outcome

Background: Infantile cleft lip and nasal severity influence the final esthetic result of the repair. Although various authors have described methods of cleft lip and nasal repair, there is a paucity of data that correlates cleft severity with esthetic outcomes. The aim of this study was to examine the correlation between presurgical severity of unilateral cleft deformity and long-term postoperative esthetic outcomes. Methods: This retrospective study, based at a single institution, investigated patients with complete unilateral cleft lip, with or without cleft palate, who underwent repair by a single surgeon, had preoperative infantile facial casts, and had postoperative facial photographs at 6 to 11 years of age (N=31). Preoperative nostril width ratio and columellar angle measurements were taken from facial casts. Postoperative, long-term nasolabial appearance was rated by 5 blinded observers used a modified Kuijpers-Jagtman scale. Linear regression was used to determine the relationship between preoperative cleft severity and postoperative ratings. Results: Preoperative nostril width ratio directly correlated with postoperative nasal form score (r=0.40; P=0.026); likewise, preoperative columellar angle predicted postoperative nasal form score (r=0.37; P=0.040). Preoperative cleft severity was not significantly correlated with vermillion border appearance. Cronbach α values of 0.91 (nasal form) and 0.79 (vermillion border) indicated good inter-rater reliability. Kappa values of 0.87 (nasal form) and 0.70 (vermillion border) indicated good intrarater reliability. Conclusions: Preoperative unilateral cleft nose severity directly correlates with long-term postoperative nasal appearance in childhood. Outcome studies should present and control for preoperative severity to allow more accurate assessment of repair techniques.